My Foray into Artisan Gelato By Way of Ice Cream: Recipe: Tamarind Ice Cream and Papaya-Mango Ice Cream

For the longest time I have had a dream that one day I would own a Gelateria – a quaint little storefront brightly colored and smelling of heavenly delights. The setting would of course be in a quaint little town, preferably historic and with cobblestones, where I would hone my creative juices to a simple yet delectable gastronomic experiment. This town would be full of people who appreciate fine foods and artistry or maybe just a constant stream of tourists looking for a unique snack. My life would essentially be like the movie Chocolat, but instead of chocolates, I would be making gelato, because just like Vianne, I believe that good food, filled with fine ingredients, that speak to people’s hearts and souls, can change lives and ultimately make people happier.
I have always had a deep respect for artisans of food. Those craftsmen and women who dedicate their lives to a single creative outlet and do it great – with purpose and passion. I am talking about cheesemakers, hand roasted coffee roasters, breadmakers, chocolatiers, vintners, olive oil producers, and farmers.
I have also always had a deep and profound love for ice cream. That soft and creamy texture that is nothing but a blank slate for all the creativity you can throw at it! So why haven’t I opened the doors to my gelateria yet? Because also in this vision, I am much older than I am now. I have been around the world, tasted a lot of frozen treats, ice creams and gelati from all over there world filling my head with an abundance of ideas and recipes, and am at the point where I am ready to throw down roots and stay somewhere for a while, putting my heart and soul and love into my creations.
However, every great gelato maker has to start somewhere right? And aren’t the guinea pigs of said gelato makers always happy too? So from this day forward, as I live my life and get closer to that gelateria dream with each step, I will begin experimenting with ice creams – and you can be my cyber-tasters. Sound good? Good. Then Enter.
Well to start you off, here are 2 delicious recipes that I have made recently:
Tamarind-Coconut
and
Papaya-Mango
First I will share with you my favorite ice cream base recipe and talk a little about gelato.
I experimented with several different bases – some were custard bases, that I found were although delicious, a little too hard in consistency for my taste and then some bases without eggs. For now, I prefer these ice cream base without eggs, as it is lighter in texture and the recipe more closely resembles my adored gelato (which does not contain eggs). On that note, the secret of making gelato is not in the ice cream base, but in the kind of machine you have. For gelato, you need a machine that churns slower than your regular counter top ice cream makers – even the good ones, like my Cuisinart. This slow churning makes the ice cream much more dense and creamy and therefore also enhances the flavor. Also ice cream typically has more air in it. Gelato is also made in small batches – this is where the true artistry comes in. Plus it is stored at a higher temperature than other ice creams, which makes it so that your taste buds aren’t numbed when you but it in your mouth, like ice cream. So because of all these reasons, I cannot actually make gelato per se, however, I can and will make really good ice cream. I am also going to try in subsequent batches, to decrease the time I let the ice cream churn, which with theoretically create less air in the ice cream.
So here is my preferred base:
INGREDIENTS:
1 1/2 cups whole milk
1 1/2 cups granulated sugar
3 cups heavy cream or half and half (half and half will make the texture more icy and light)
1 1/2 TABLESPOONS of Tahitian vanilla extract (I have found that using vanilla extract enhances the other flavors you add and makes the taste of the ice cream more qualitative as ice-creaminess).
METHOD:
In a medium mixing bowl, use a hand mixer on low speed to combine the milk and granulated sugar, until the sugar has dissolved (about 1-2 minutes). Stir in the heavy cream and the vanilla. Place into the bowl of your ice cream maker and follow the manufacturers directions.
Okay, now for my recipes.
Tamarind Coconut Ice Cream
INGREDIENTS:
12 dried tamarind pods, pods removed and pulp soaked in warm water for about 1/2 hour, seeds removed
3 dried unsulfured Turkish apricots
1 1/2 cups coconut milk
1 cup granulated sugar
1/2 cup brown sugar, unpacked
3 cups heavy cream
1/2 TBS Tahitian Vanilla extract
1 TBS tamarind syrup (like coffee syrups – I found this in a Latin market)
METHOD:
Soak the tamarind pods (pods removed) and apricots in warm water for about 1/2 hour. Remove seeds from pulp and pulverize pulp and apricots in a food processor. Add the coconut milk and sugars to the food processor and whiz until mixed and the sugar is dissolved. Add in the heavy cream, vanilla extract and tamarind syrup and blend. Pour mixture into the bowl of your ice cream maker and follow the manufacturers directions.
This ice cream is phenomenal and our favorite as of yet. If you have never had tamarinds before, the taste of this ice cream is like the ripest of black cherries with the slight tang of the apricots enhancing the already apricot-y nature of tamarinds. Combined with the warmth of the vanilla and the sweetness of the coconut, you are in gastronomic paradise. I am telling you, this is amazing stuff and it hearkens back to my memory of that luscious Tamarind Milkshake of my past.
Papaya-Mango Ice Cream
INGREDIENTS:
1 cup fresh papaya
1 ripe mango
1 1/2 cups whole milk
1 1/2 cups granulated sugar
3 cups heavy cream
1/2 TBS Tahitian Vanilla extract
METHOD:
Same as the above recipe, except that you pulverize the mango and papaya fruit first – no soaking necessary. Add the milk and sugar to the food processor and whiz until mixed and the sugar is dissolved. Add in the heavy cream and vanilla extract and blend. Pour mixture into the bowl of your ice cream maker and follow the manufacturers directions.
Papaya is my favorite fruit followed closely in second place by mango. We had a leftover mango from making Elle’s Mango Buffalo Wings, and I always have a partially eaten papaya in the fridge, so I figured why not? Luckily I also have some yummy yogurt, mango and lime sauce left over from that recipe, which is likely to be featured in an ice cream soon.

A question often arises, can ice cream be made if you do not have an ice cream maker? The answer is yes, but it is annoying. After the ice cream is made and not yet frozen, pour it into a freezer safe bowl and freeze for about an hour, take it out, and break it into chunks, and then whiz it in your food processor, blending it again. Then re-freeze for another hour and repeat until it is the desired consistency and frozeness. My suggestion…if you really love ice cream and you really want to make it at home – get a machine. It is worth the time you will spend if you don’t have one.
I would also like to take this oppurtunity to thank Andhra Flavors of For Spicy Lovers for awarding me with :

It really means so much! Especially coming from such a *spicy* blog! Consider you all awarded!






Judy - May 21, 2008 at 11:02 am
You have just talked me into it. I am going out today and buying an ice cream maker…I have been pondering it for a while but with summer coming it is a must have!!! Can I tell hubby that you made me do it???
Catherine - May 21, 2008 at 12:01 pm
In a way, your dream IS coming true…you are inspiring others to follow their own food dreams, and perhaps that is the way your little “gelateria” becomes real! Like Judy, now I’m convinced that I can do this and will buy a maker.
Tanya - May 21, 2008 at 12:28 pm
Hello! I LOVE gelato! I was in heaven when my husband and I were in Europe for our honeymoon. We must have had gelato every day. A gelato place in an awesome idea because it’s still a relatively small market, especially if you don’t live in a huge city.
By the way, for some reason I received a free subscription to “Frozen Desserts Magazine.” It’s a trade magazine aimed mainly at professionals, but if you’re ever looking into opening a gelato place, it’s a pretty cool magazine. They’re still giving away free subscriptions on their website (www.frozendessertsmagazine.com).
courtney - May 21, 2008 at 12:31 pm
I did not know that about gelato! I have a box of tamarind pods. I will be using my ice cream maker. Was actually thinking of making Spumoni soon.Great recipes.
Haley W. - May 21, 2008 at 1:57 pm
Yum! The tamarind-coconut ice cream sounds amazing – the world needs more tamarind recipes in it. I feel like I need to run out and buy an ice cream maker now.
Patsyk - May 21, 2008 at 2:08 pm
I adore ice cream and gelato! Just reading your post made me wish you had opened your storefront nearby my home so I could come and personally try your creations!
jen of a2eatwrite - May 21, 2008 at 2:32 pm
I’m so excited to try this because I haven’t found a base I really like. I’m staying away from the tamarind, though – tamarind and I don’t mix, for some reason. The mango/papaya looks heavenly, though!
Peter G - May 21, 2008 at 4:12 pm
Gimme molto gelato per favore! Yes, gelato is that special dish that really leaves a mark on your taste buds. Who needs a quaint shop when you have Cuisinart!…LOL. Seriously Jenn, these are very creative flavours and very authentic. I love the tamarind/coconut combo.
Deborah - May 21, 2008 at 5:06 pm
This sounds absolutely delicious! I haven’t even had a good gelato in too long…
toontz - May 21, 2008 at 7:23 pm
I love gelato, too! Thank you for the lesson in tamarinds. I did not know what they were, so now I will keep my eye out for them.
Ben - May 21, 2008 at 7:50 pm
Jenn, this post is so lovely. First because I’ve had that same dream, only that I own a reposteria (bakery) where empanadas are made all day every day. Maybe my reposteria can be next to your gelateria. This are two great ice creams. I especially love the mango-papaya one. It reminds me of home
Brittany - May 21, 2008 at 7:57 pm
Jenn, you are a woman after my own heart. Ice cream is my favorite dessert (duh- who wants pie with out a melty scoop?), I love how there are no limits to it. (sidenote- I made a pistachio ice cream at work last week that made me think of you. I know you had done a gelateria post a while back and you were somewhat unimpressed buy the pistachio…I wanted to somehow send a bite of the finished product to Florida, as there were plenty of candied pistachios flecked through out each scoop)
I want to live in your dream town. Maybe open a pie shop next door?
Call me- I’ll be there.
Sylvia - May 21, 2008 at 9:27 pm
Oh Jenn your post is lovely, I admire you a lot, honestly, and always is a great pleasure come here and read you. Ice cream in Argentina had the same style as in Italy creamily and delicious ..yum yum
I love tamarind and when I lived in Brazil I usually used like lemon or drink as a juice
Britt - May 21, 2008 at 11:32 pm
What an exciting read! I love gelato, but never considered making it myself, as the concept seemed complicated. You have since changed my mind, and I am looking forward to this summer treasure!
Nina - May 22, 2008 at 1:48 am
I once heard a very wise man say: “What we want to get rid of today, we once desired with our whole being.” With that said, I bet there was a time when you’ve dreamt about having a successful website and now you are living that dream. I have no doubt that you will one day own your dream shop, but Jenn you ARE A TRUE ARTISAN….and so say all of us!
As for the flavors in your ice-cream – you rock!!!!
canarygirl - May 22, 2008 at 6:36 am
Your tamarind and coconut ice-cream is just GENIUS! Do you think I could use tamarind paste in place of the pods?
Helen - May 22, 2008 at 7:11 am
Wow! I love your romantic vision Jenn and I’m sure you can achieve it when you are older and ready! I think you’ve made a pretty good start with these recipes, I love that tamarind-coconut idea.
Bellini Valli - May 22, 2008 at 9:04 am
Now I’m feeling sorry muself that I just ate the addictive tamarinds that you sent me Jenn. Does St. Augustine have cobbled streets??..it does have history and everything else you mentioned:D
kittie - May 22, 2008 at 11:20 am
Jenn – that was a beautiful post – I’m now craving gelato (or even just some very good icecream
And considering buying a machine – though I have no space for it…
The Leftover Queen - May 22, 2008 at 11:26 am
Yes, Judy! Please feel free to blame me! I will happily take the blame for all things ice cream!
Thanks Catherine! Thanks for saying such nice things. I guess I don’t really see what I am doing in that same glowy light, but yeah, I love to see people follow their dream! If I have anything to do with it, I am very honored!
Hey Tanya! Man, I find a way to eat gelato or ice cream everyday.One of the reasons I asked for the machine! There are lots of Gelatarias around here, and it is like almost $5 a pop! I signed up for the mag, thanks for the heads up!
Yum! Spumoni! As you know, it is a childhood favorite of mine! I should make it too! Hope you make the tamarind!
Haley! Go buy one and blame it on me! The world needs more ice cream!
Hey PatsyK! I hope one day that can be true!
Hey Jen! Lemme know what you think of the base. I do think I am going to churn it less next time. Hopefully it will be more dense that way. So you and tamarind don’t get along, huh? Bummer.
Thanks so much Peter G! I know, I love my Cuisinart, but I want to share my gelato with others and be accountable – which I think will make my creations all the more creative – I love a good challenge!
Deborah! That is so not right!!! I wish I could send you some!
No problem Toontz! I am sure you will come up with something creative when you get your hands on some!
Thanks so much Ben!
Maybe we should get a whole block of stores somewhere and all of us that wants a specialty food store of some kind can come and it would be the bestest street EVER!
Brittany, I am so gonna call you! That would be awesome! You and Ben and who else, who else?????
That just tickles me pink! – but then again I hate pink…so how about tickling me chartreuse ??
BTW, I am so happy that pistachio ice cream made you think of me!
Thank you SO MUCH Sylvia! That means a lot coming from you as I feel the same way about you and your blog.Hmmm..I never thought to use Tamarind like lemon. I should try that. And as a side note, I knew I wanted to come to Argentina!
Thanks Britt! Glad to have dispelled your ice cream fears!
Cones up!
NINA! THANK YOU! You are just so sweet and I really appreciate your entire comment, from the quote to your interpretation of it. You are so right. I truly believe that you can do anything you put your mind to. That is what makes life so exciting! Watching dreams come true (both for ourselves and others)!
Thank you so much Nikki! Yes, I think tamarind paste would actually be much easier – no soaking of pods and food processing necessary!
Thanks Helen! I look forward to the day! And I am having so much fun already!
LOL! Valli! I am so sorry! I am out too. If I find another good supply I will send you some more! Yes as a matter of fact Saint Augustine is a very good candidate for this venture!
Andy - May 22, 2008 at 11:37 am
Those look amazing. I still remember eating gelato in Italy two summers ago…delicious stuff. I really want to learn to make good ice cream. Is there any chance you could find a machine that will churn slower for gelato?
The Leftover Queen - May 22, 2008 at 12:13 pm
Kittie! You snuck in there!
Well, if this makes you feel better, my machine is in my laundry closet sharing space with the guest towels!
Thanks Andy! You can find Gelato makers, but they don’t really make them for the home market. They are over $1,000 generally and gargantuan!
Cris - May 22, 2008 at 1:19 pm
I’m impressed with the combination of mango and papaya, which I eat everyday in a bowl along with other fruits, but never thought of combining them for ice-cream dessert, you rock!
Lisa - May 22, 2008 at 2:43 pm
If I had an ice cream maker, I would make one of these recipes as soon as I return home from work. Alas, I will have to be content to drool over your beautiful photographs. An informative and entertaining post Jenn!
T.W. Barritt at Culinary Types - May 22, 2008 at 2:43 pm
How wonderful!!!! Makes me want to start the summer season this weekend! I share your dream – of course, I’d be happy to just live in the type of community you describe!
Ruth E - May 22, 2008 at 4:25 pm
I’m trying to avoid eating too many treats at the minute and this is very tempting!!!!
Beautiful photos…. as usual!
Kat - May 22, 2008 at 4:43 pm
Now I’m tempted to get the ice cream maker attachment for the Kitchen Aid
Maggie - May 22, 2008 at 6:49 pm
I’ve been waiting for the longest time to get an ice cream maker. Other than new pots, which I’ve been holding off on for years, its the most looked forward to purchase for when we move into our new house later this year. I’m dying to get my son off of his Tofutti habit and find some dairy-free ice cream recipes that are more wholesome. I have to save your tamarind-coconut recipe for myself though. It sounds awesome!
Kevin - May 22, 2008 at 8:48 pm
Both of those gelatos sound really good! I have been wanting to try using tamarind more including trying to find some pods rather that using the processed pastes.
Heather - May 22, 2008 at 11:20 pm
I love gelato too. But even more, I love your romantic gelateria fantasies!
Holly - May 23, 2008 at 12:18 am
The pictures of your gelato are incredible, but when you find that village let me know because it sounds just like the one I’ve been dreaming of too!
Maria - May 23, 2008 at 12:51 am
Hi Jenn,
I really enjoy nutty gelato flavours like almonds and pistachios. I think icecreams/gelato’s are great.. but they’re not something I go out of my way to eat or choose off a menu. Still.. I do have a plan to one day own an icecream maker because I can imagine making up exotic flavours like wild fig and rose for dinner guests. I do hope you get your gelato shop and seduce your local community with your cool, creamy offerings
núria - May 23, 2008 at 3:43 am
If I send you my daughter over… she would be the happiest person on earth to be your guinea pig… She LOVES ice creams!!! So, I’m writting your marvellous recipes down! Now I only need the machine… My santa’s list this year is going to be looooooooong!!!!
I love the mango/papaya picture
Hope your dream comes true!!!
The Leftover Queen - May 23, 2008 at 10:39 am
Thanks Cris! I also eat papaya daily – usually along with some melons. I am telling you, papaya is good in anything!
Thanks Lisa! If only you lived near by, I would give you some! Glad you enjoyed the post!
Well, TW, I will let you know when I find it for sure! It is hard to avoid summer around these parts!
Hey Ruth! There is always sorbet and Fro-yo! I will have to develop a low-sugar variety. But NOT with artificial poison.
Do it, Kat! DO IT!
Yes, Maggie, that is why I wanted one so much. First, I need to support my habit and it is much cheaper than purchasing ice cream – either at a shop or the market AND this way I can control what I put in it. Very important things to me in this day.
Totally Kevin! You can’t beat the convenience of the pastes, but the pods are really fun to work with.
Thanks Heather! It is a fantasy I plan to put into action! I believe you can imagine things into reality – so why not a gelateria?!
Okay Holly! Will do! Sounds like a lot of us would like to move there too!
Thanks Maria! I cannot imagine life without ice cream. It would be so…sad. But others feel the way I feel about ice cream and gelato for chocolate. So that is what makes cooking so amazing! I love fig gelato! In fact, I love fig everything!
Okay Nuria!
I would love to see what else is on your Santa list this year! I am sure it could give me some ideas! Thanks sweetie!
steamy kitchen - May 24, 2008 at 8:47 am
love the tamarind coconut one! great combo of flavors…
Sue - May 24, 2008 at 1:49 pm
I hope your gelato making continues, even without the shop.
I LOVE tamarind and this looks like an unusual and delicious use for it. Can’t wait to try it!
MyKitchenInHalfCups - May 24, 2008 at 4:26 pm
Thanks for the info on the gelato and ice cream differences. I could only have told you I love gelato! I think that tamarind coconut must have been wonderful!
jasmine - May 25, 2008 at 11:27 am
I adore your writing–really drew me in. The flavours you came up with are great and I hope you continue making and sharing these frozen treats…
j
The Leftover Queen - May 27, 2008 at 11:43 am
Thanks Jaden! It was awesome, I must say!
Thanks Sue, I promise that it will continue – I am an ice cream/ gelato addict with no interest in being cut off!
Thanks Tanna! Isn’t it interesting!?
Thanks so much Jasmine! I am so glad you stopped by and like what you read! Stay tuned for more!
foodhoe - May 27, 2008 at 4:07 pm
Ooh, tamarind and coconut ice cream sounds so interesting and fabulous!
Cakelaw - May 27, 2008 at 11:14 pm
All I can say is YUM!
Michele - June 9, 2008 at 7:58 pm
Hey, your blog is really cool, interesting, and fun… and I’m wondering if you would care to contribute something to our new website:
http://www.chefswithoutfrontiers.com
Maybe a reprint of one of your blogs, or something new. We concentrate on interesting stories around eating, cooking, entertaining, and everything food – not so much recipes, although they are welcome if they are a part of a story. We’d love to have your presence on the site, and we certainly would link back to your blog with pleasure!
Hope to hear from you,
all the best,
Michele Kadison
growitgreen - July 18, 2008 at 9:14 am
I love gelato, I havent found a shop in my small town in S.C that makes it so I have to make it myself when I get a craving. I appreciate all of the recipes I can get my hands on.
Check out this “cool” article at “http://www.foosita.com
Andrea - August 1, 2008 at 12:27 am
I really love these flavor combinations.